Vested without a Hearing

The Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2026, would let the Centre take over the property of any organisation whose foreign-contribution certificate lapses, and sell it. The Bill gives a hearing and an appeal only after the property has vested, and the Rules already in force define the test that decides which certificates lapse. This essay follows the chain from that Rule to the sale, checks it against what the Supreme Court has decided on foreign funding and on property, and sets out what the Joint Committee could change before it reports.

On 18 September, at the first meeting of the Joint Committee on the Bill, the Home Ministry gave members two sets of numbers. The count of active FCRA-registered organisations had fallen from 29,022 in 2015 to 14,466. Foreign contribution to them had gone up from Rs 17,832 crore in 2015-16 to Rs 22,974 crore in 2024-25. The Ministry presented both figures while defending the Bill, and I keep returning to the pair. Half the organisations are gone and the money has grown. The Bill adds a new consequence for the organisations that fail to keep a certificate.

The Bill was introduced in the Lok Sabha on 25 March 2026 and its Statement of Objects and Reasons is signed by Home Minister Amit Shah and dated 19 March. On 12 August the House referred it to a 31-member Joint Committee, 21 members from the Lok Sabha and 10 from the Rajya Sabha, with Sanjay Jaiswal of the BJP in the chair. The motion told the Committee to report by the last day of the first week of the Winter Session. The Winter Session dates have not been announced, so that deadline has no calendar date yet.

This essay is about one chain of events that the Bill and the Rules complete between them. A Rule decides which organisations are treated as inactive. A new section says that an organisation which fails renewal has lost its certificate automatically. A new chapter says that its foreign-funded property, and any property it partly built with domestic money, passes to a Designated Authority that can run its activities, and later sell what it holds. Each step comes from the text of the Bill. I then set the chain against the Supreme Court’s 2022 judgment on the 2020 amendments and its 2024 judgment on property, give the case for the Bill as its defenders would make it, and list the changes I would put to the Committee.

From the Rule to the sale

The FCRA Amendment Rules, 2026, notified on 22 June as S.O. 3272(E), define something the Act never defined. Under the Act, a certificate can be cancelled or a renewal refused if the organisation has not undertaken “reasonable activity”. The new Rule 14A treats an organisation as active only if it has spent at least Rs 10 lakh of foreign contribution in the last two financial years. KPMG and AZB both report the same figure, and PRS has reviewed the Rules.

Clause 9 of the Bill inserts a new section 14B. A certificate is deemed to have ceased on expiry if the organisation has not applied for renewal, if it applied and was refused, or if the certificate “is not renewed before its expiry”. The third limb needs a second look. It does not ask whether the organisation applied. An organisation whose application is still pending when the certificate expires falls within it. An opinion piece in ThePrint by Ajay Mallareddy of the Centre for Liberty makes this reading and adds that the Ministry’s public notices extending the validity of certificates for pending applicants are administrative choices, which the Bill does not convert into a guarantee.

Clause 11 inserts a new Chapter IIIA, and its section 16A does the work. When a certificate is cancelled, surrendered or has ceased under 14B, the foreign contribution and “the assets created out of foreign contribution” vest provisionally in the Designated Authority from the date of cessation. If the organisation does not obtain a fresh, renewed or restored certificate within a period that the Rules will fix, the vesting becomes permanent. The Authority then applies the assets to public purposes and may transfer them to a Ministry, department or local authority, or sell them, and the sale proceeds and any foreign contribution not yet spent go to the Consolidated Fund of India. Sub-section 16A(6) also bars the organisation’s key functionaries from acquiring any interest in what is sold.

The figure below shows the path.

Path from a lapsed certificate to the sale of assets under the Bill. Source: Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2026, clauses 9 and 11 (proposed sections 14B and 16A to 16L); FCRA Amendment Rules, 2026, Rule 14A, as summarised by PRS Legislative Research.

What Vests, and what the Authority can do with it

Sub-section 16A(2) says an asset “shall vest wholly” in the Authority even if it was created “partly from foreign contribution and partly from other sources”. The organisation may apply for the return of any “distinct or ascertainable portion” that came from other sources, and the Authority returns it if it is satisfied. PRS gives the example of a hospital that raised both domestic and foreign donations for a new ward. Where donations are pooled, no distinct domestic portion may be identifiable, and the route back could be closed in practice. The Bill puts the burden of tracing on the organisation. A rule that put it on the Authority would cost the state something and would protect domestic money.

The Authority’s powers go past custody. Under sub-section 16A(3)(b), where it considers it “necessary or expedient” in the public interest, it may take over the management of the activities of the organisation whose assets have vested provisionally, in the manner and for the period the Rules prescribe. Section 16F requires the organisation and every key functionary to hand over books, keys, bank accounts and lockers, to keep the assets intact, and to carry on their activities “under the supervision of” the Authority. Section 16G gives the Authority and its Administrator the powers of a civil court in summoning witnesses and demanding documents, and deems them public servants.

Four of the most consequential variables are left to rules. The period within which an organisation may regain its certificate, the conditions on which assets come back, the manner of sale and the scope of management are all in the Memorandum on Delegated Legislation under clause 19, which calls them “matters of procedure and administrative detail”. A period that decides whether a school passes to the state is a matter of substance, and the statute gives it no floor. In Assent without effect I followed four statutes from assent to legal effect and found that much of their content arrived later, in rules that no member votes on. This Bill follows that pattern.

Section 16B reaches backwards in one specific way. It applies the amended Act to everything already vested under the old section 15 and deems all of it provisionally vested in the new Authority from the date the Amendment Act commences. Whether the new section 14B also catches certificates that lapsed before that date is a question the text leaves open. PRS says the Bill applies vesting to organisations that held a certificate, did not renew it and went on operating on domestic funds, and gives a hospital built with FCRA funds as its example. The Bill says nothing on the point, and the Committee should settle it. The portal shows 15,212 certificates “deemed expired”, and Mallareddy reports that the government cites about 15,000 ceased registrations, with their funds and assets in limbo, in support of the Bill.

Where the Hearing is

The Act already gives an organisation a hearing before cancellation and a High Court appeal against cancellation, rejection of a registration application or confiscation of currency. PRS notes that it gives no hearing and no appeal against refusal of a renewal, and that the Bill does not add one. Section 14B makes cessation automatic, which means there is no order to challenge. Vesting under 16A(1) follows from the date of cessation.

The Bill does contain remedies. Section 16J lets the Authority revise its own orders within 90 days. Section 16K gives an aggrieved person an appeal, within 90 days, to the District Judge in whose jurisdiction the vesting, management or disposal took place, or to a Senior Civil Judge the Centre may specify, subject to limits to be prescribed. Section 16A(4)(c) recognises restoration “by revision under section 32” of the Act, though the Bill does not describe that route. Each of these runs against an order of the Authority or a decision of the Centre taken after the property has vested. None applies before. Mallareddy adds that Article 226 petitions remain open and no substitute for a hearing before the property is taken.

What the Supreme Court has and has not decided

The decision everyone cites is Noel Harper v Union of India, decided on 8 April 2022 by a bench of Justices A M Khanwilkar, Dinesh Maheshwari and C T Ravikumar. The petitions challenged the 2020 amendments to sections 7, 12A, 12(1A) and 17(1): the ban on passing foreign contribution to other organisations, the Aadhaar requirement for office-bearers, and the rule that foreign money must come into a designated State Bank of India account. The Court upheld the amendments. According to SC Observer’s summary, it read the section 7 ban narrowly and allowed Indian nationals to give passports in place of Aadhaar. Nishith Desai’s note reports the Court’s view that the right to receive foreign contribution is not a fundamental right, and SC Observer’s analysis records the sovereignty reasoning.

The judgment is a strong precedent for the proposition that Parliament may regulate the inflow of foreign money tightly. It does not answer the question the 2026 Bill raises, which is what happens to assets after the inflow has stopped. The provisions before the Court in Noel Harper were sections 7, 12A, 12(1A) and 17(1). Vesting under section 15, Article 300A and a hearing before cancellation were not among them.

The nearer authority is Kolkata Municipal Corporation v Bimal Kumar Shah, decided on 16 May 2024 by Justices P S Narasimha and Aravind Kumar. The Court held that Article 300A requires “authority of law”, and that a law depriving a person of property must carry seven sub-rights: notice, a hearing, a reasoned decision, acquisition only for a public purpose, restitution or compensation, an efficient procedure, and a conclusion to the process. The case concerned compulsory acquisition by a municipal corporation, and a two-judge bench decided it. It does not decide the FCRA question. Held against the Bill, the picture is mixed. The Bill states a public purpose in 16A(6). It gives no prior notice or hearing, and the proceeds go to the Consolidated Fund and not to the organisation.

The government has a reply. It can say that vesting under the Bill is a consequence attached to a statutory licence, in the same way that the licence itself is conditional, and that it is a regulatory forfeiture and not an acquisition of private property. That argument has more force for the foreign-funded portion of an asset than for the domestic portion. The word “wholly” in 16A(2) is where the property argument is strongest, because it sweeps in money that never came from abroad.

Several writers have made the Article 300A point, including Zulfiker Ali in LiveLaw, Yash Raj in LiveLaw and a ThePrint opinion piece that frames the question as proportionality. Mohneesh Rai at the Oxford Human Rights Hub sets the Bill against the statement in Noel Harper that there is no fundamental right to receive foreign contributions. A piece from Jindal Global University adds Article 30, which protects the right of minorities to run educational institutions.

What the numbers show and what they cannot

The Ministry’s figures need care before they are used. The 29,022 and the 14,466 count organisations that the Ministry calls active. An earlier answer in Parliament gave 33,216 organisations registered on 31 October 2016, which is a different definition, and 22,691 active organisations in August 2021. The fall from 29,022 to 14,466 is 50.2 per cent, and it depends on which count one starts from. The portal figures that PRS reports for July 2026 are 14,449 active certificates, 22,498 cancelled and 15,212 deemed expired. PRS’s text gives the date as 15 July, but its footnote says the portal was accessed on 6 May, and it does not reconcile the two. The chart below shows the three.

Status of FCRA certificates, July 2026. Source: PRS Legislative Research, Legislative Brief on the FCRA Amendment Bill, 2026 (15 July 2026), citing the FCRA portal, Ministry of Home Affairs. PRS gives both 15 July and 6 May as the date of access.

Foreign contribution rose by Rs 5,142 crore, or 28.8 per cent, between 2015-16 and 2024-25. These are nominal rupees, so adjusted for prices the increase is smaller. Divided across the organisations, the average amount per active registration rises from about Rs 61 lakh to about Rs 159 lakh. That is a crude figure, because it mixes a registry count with receipts and many registered organisations receive nothing in a given year. It still shows that the money now sits with fewer organisations.

Active FCRA-registered organisations and foreign contribution received, as reported by the Ministry of Home Affairs to the Joint Committee. Source: Ministry of Home Affairs briefing to the Joint Committee, 18 September 2026, as reported by PTI. The two measures cover different periods: organisations in 2015 and on 18 September 2026; contribution in 2015-16 and 2024-25.

What the numbers cannot tell us is why certificates ended. A defender of the Bill would say that many were dormant, had stopped filing returns or had broken the rules, and that about 22,000 certificates have been cancelled since 2010, by ICNL’s count. Al Jazeera’s liberties newsletter reports 21,933 licences lost as of 26 March and says that groups working on minority rights, free expression and climate action were disproportionately affected. The Ministry’s figures do not say why any certificate ended. The aggregates support a narrower claim than the critics make. They show that the filter on who may receive foreign money has tightened for a decade and that the Bill attaches a consequence to failing it. They do not show how many of the organisations that failed it deserved to.

How the Rule feeds the chain

The Rs 10 lakh test connects the Rules to the Bill. Development-sector commentary notes that only activity funded from foreign contribution counts towards it, so an organisation that is busy on domestic money can still fail. PRS gives the example of a rural library that cost Rs 20 lakh to set up and about Rs 4 lakh a year to run. The brief says the library could be lost although it operates. At Rs 4 lakh a year, even if every rupee were foreign, the library spends Rs 8 lakh in two years, which is under the line. Rs 10 lakh over two years is an average of Rs 5 lakh a year, and small organisations will fall below it.

The incentive this creates is one the Bill’s own logic ought to worry about. An organisation with property that foreign money once helped to build can protect it only by continuing to take and spend at least Rs 5 lakh a year of foreign money. Mallareddy makes the same argument. An organisation that has weaned itself off foreign funding, which is the outcome a sovereignty rationale would favour, becomes the one most exposed.

PRS adds a separate point about the Rules. They define “key functionary” in a way that may go beyond the scope of delegated legislation, because the Act has no such class. The Bill supplies the missing definition in clause 3(f), so the Rule precedes the statute that would give it a basis.

The case for the Bill

The Statement of Objects and Reasons gives the government’s argument, and it has weight. Section 15 of the Act provides for vesting but, in the Statement’s words, the lack of a comprehensive framework for supervising and disposing of vested assets has led to “administrative uncertainty and scope for misuse”. An opinion writer reports that Rule 12(6A), added in 2020, already extended temporary vesting to organisations whose certificates were deemed to have ceased. On that account the Bill moves an existing practice into a statute and attaches remedies to it, which is a gain in procedure.

Several features of the Bill favour the organisations.

The Bill cuts the maximum prison term for contravention from five years to one. Section 35 as substituted allows imprisonment of up to a year, a fine or both. It requires the Centre’s prior approval before an investigation can begin for any offence, and the Statement lists the “multiplicity of investigations” among the problems the Bill addresses. Vesting is provisional first and reverses if the certificate is restored. Places of worship are protected by 16A(7), which requires the Authority to keep their religious character. Section 16L allows the Centre to exempt a person or class of persons from the chapter. Appeals against the Authority’s orders lie to a district court.

The Supreme Court accepted sovereignty as a legitimate ground for tight regulation in Noel Harper. ICNL’s timeline records that the Financial Action Task Force found India only partly compliant on non-profit organisations in September 2024. And money that sits with a defunct organisation has no owner who can answer for it, so some process for such cases is needed. Section 16C covers that case: where an organisation ceases to exist, the last key functionaries must tell the Centre and its foreign-funded assets vest permanently.

The prior-approval clause deserves a second look. It reduces what lower-level officers can do to an organisation. It also puts the decision with the Centre, the same authority that regulates the organisations, so I would not call it a safeguard without a record of how approvals are given.

Other changes in the Bill

Under the substituted section 39, every “key functionary” who was in charge of the organisation when an offence was committed is deemed guilty, and escapes only if he proves that the offence happened without his knowledge or that he took all due diligence. The new definition in clause 3(f) includes directors, partners, trustees, office-bearers and members of a governing body, and any other person who has control over or responsibility for the management of the organisation. The burden of proof sits with the individual. Clause 5 also widens the condition in section 12(4)(e), under which no director or office-bearer may have a conviction or pending prosecution, so that it applies to key functionaries.

The Bill also changes the ban on foreign funds for news and current affairs. Section 3(1)(g) of the Act bars an “association or company” that produces or broadcasts audio or audio-visual news or current affairs programmes through any electronic mode, or any other mode of mass communication, from accepting foreign contribution. Clause 4(a) of the Bill replaces “association or company” with “person”. The Act’s definition of a person includes an individual. An individual who produces news content through a podcast or a video channel is therefore brought within the bar. PRS’s brief does not discuss this change. It comes from the text of the Bill.

The process so far

The Committee met for the first time on 18 September, when Home Secretary Govind Mohan briefed members and Jaiswal said the panel was confident of reporting before the Winter Session. The Home and Law ministries gave a clause-by-clause briefing on 29 September. On 12 October the Committee heard stakeholders including the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India and the Catholic Bishops Conference of India, and Jaiswal said it had listened to all views and would deliberate in its own meeting. On 12 November, at its sixth sitting, it was due to hear 14 stakeholders, among them Oxfam, BAPS and church leaders.

A committee report is a set of recommendations. The government decides which of them to move as amendments when the Bill returns to the House, and the Committee’s report is the stage at which the text of the Bill is most open to change.

What the Committee could change

I would put five amendments to the Committee.

Vesting could be limited to the portion of an asset that is shown to have come from foreign contribution, with the Authority bearing the burden of showing it. That removes the word “wholly” from 16A(2) and keeps the state’s claim over the money that came from abroad.

A cessation that results from non-renewal could require a reasoned order after notice and a hearing, with a pending renewal application stopping the clock. That would address 14B(1)(c) and give the organisation something to challenge before vesting.

The period for regaining a certificate, and the Authority’s power to manage an organisation’s activities under 16A(3)(b), could be fixed in the statute. A floor on the period, and a bar on taking over activities unless the certificate was cancelled for a proven violation, would put the two most serious powers under Parliament’s eye.

An appeal could lie against a refusal of renewal, to a High Court as the Act now provides for cancellation.

Section 16B and the commencement clause could say plainly that vesting applies only to cessations after the Amendment Act takes effect. If the government wants earlier lapses covered, the Bill should say so and defend it.

Further reading

The Bill and the Rules

Bill text as introduced (PRS) · PRS Bill page · PRS Legislative Brief · PRS review of the 2026 Rules · KPMG on the Rules · AZB on the Rules

Courts

Noel Harper v Union of India (Indian Kanoon) · SC Observer judgment summary · ICNL analysis of the judgment · Kolkata Municipal Corporation v Bimal Kumar Shah (Supreme Court)

Critique and comment

Ajay Mallareddy in ThePrint · ThePrint on regulatory pressure on non-profits · Oxford Human Rights Hub · ICNL briefer, August 2026 update

The Committee

First meeting, 18 September · Ministry briefing, 29 September · Hearing, 12 October · Hearing notice, 12 November

Earlier on policygrounds

Assent without effect · Recorded as stated


Varna is a development economist and writes at policygrounds.press.

Write a comment ...

Varna

Show your support

If you've found value in my writing, consider supporting ImpactMojo (www.impactmojo.in)—a free, open-source knowledge platform I founded to make high-quality monitoring, evaluation, and development practice resources accessible to practitioners across South Asia. Your contribution helps us keep all courses, tools, and learning materials freely available to the thousands of development professionals who can't access expensive certifications or paywalled knowledge. Every donation goes directly toward developing new content, maintaining our interactive labs, and expanding resources that bridge the gap between academic rigour and on-the-ground practice. Thank you for helping democratise development knowledge.

Recent Supporters

Write a comment ...