Assent Without Effect

Parliament can pass a Bill in an afternoon. The law it creates can take years to bind anyone, and those years pass in rule-making that no member votes on. This essay follows four statutes from assent to legal effect and sets the months that passed against the hours Parliament gave each one. It argues against itself where the record requires it, because the committee route has not worked cleanly either.

At the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, a scheme reached a city in two steps. The first was the approval or the notification, which made the news. The second was the operational guidelines, which decided whether a municipality could spend anything under the scheme. That second step came with no announcement and no date, and a city that had been told it was covered waited until the paper arrived.

I did not think of that wait as a property of the law. It was the next document in the file. Years later, reading how Parliament passes Bills, I saw the same two steps at a larger scale: a statute that passes with a vote and a headline, and a set of rules that follow with neither.

This essay is about the gap between the day a Bill becomes an Act and the day the Act changes what anyone must do. I will call that gap the lag. Parliament controls the first date. The executive controls the second, and it fills the interval with drafting that is published late and put to no vote.

My argument is narrow. Of the four statutes below, two show lags of two to six years, one shows a lag of six months after full committee scrutiny, and one was repealed within months. The rule-making stage, where the long lags are spent, has no committee, division or debate. I cannot show that more scrutiny at the Bill stage would have shortened any lag, and the criminal law case points the other way. I say what the evidence supports and what it does not.

How often Bills go to a committee

Parliament created the departmentally related Standing Committees in 1993. PRS Legislative Research counts that since 2004 only 45 per cent of Bills introduced have been referred to a committee, and notes that Britain sends every Bill other than a Money Bill to one.

The share has moved a great deal between Lok Sabhas. PRS reports 60 per cent for the 14th, 71 per cent for the 15th and 27 per cent for the 16th. For the 17th it fell to 16 per cent, the lowest of the four, with four Bills sent to Joint Parliamentary Committees and one to a Rajya Sabha Select Committee. For the 18th Lok Sabha the share stood at 21 per cent at the close of the Monsoon Session on 13 August 2026.

Figure 1. Share of Bills referred to Committees, 14th to 18th Lok Sabha

Figure 1. Share of Bills referred to Committees, 14th to 18th Lok Sabha. Source: PRS Legislative Research, Vital Stats (Winter Session 2022 for the 14th to 16th; Functioning of the 17th Lok Sabha, 10 February 2024; Monsoon Session 2026 for the 18th). The 18th figure runs to 13 August 2026.

Referral is only one route to scrutiny. The other is time on the floor. Business Standard, citing PRS data, reported in August 2023 that 58.2 per cent of Bills introduced in the 17th Lok Sabha were passed by both Houses in the same session they were introduced. The comparable figures were 17.5 per cent in the 15th and 33.3 per cent in the 16th. The same report put the share of Bills sent to Standing Committees at 17.6 per cent at that point, against PRS’s final 16 per cent for the whole term.

Figure 2. Bills introduced and passed by both Houses in the same session

Figure 2. Bills introduced and passed by both Houses in the same session. Source: PRS Legislative Research, as reported by Business Standard, 29 August 2023. Counts are 38 of 217 (15th), 63 of 189 (16th) and 102 of 175 (17th, to August 2023).

The pattern has continued into the current House. A Daily Pioneer report on PRS data puts the share of Bills passed in the session they were introduced at 53 per cent since 2024. In the Winter Session of 2025, PRS recorded nine Bills introduced, seven passed and two referred to committees.

One point belongs here because it cuts against a lazy reading. Committees have not gone idle. The Wire’s summary of PRS figures says the Parliamentary Committees of the 17th Lok Sabha held about 1,700 meetings. The machinery exists and works. Ministers choose how often to use it for legislation.

Four statutes and the months that followed

I take four cases. Each has a passage date, an assent date, and a date on which the law first bound someone. Figure 3 shows the months, which are my arithmetic from those dates.

Figure 3. Months from Presidential assent to legal effect, selected statutes

Figure 3. Months from Presidential assent to legal effect, selected statutes. Source: author’s calculation from assent, commencement and rules dates in PRS Legislative Research and Gazette notifications. The end point differs by row. The Code on Wages had a few provisions in force from 18 December 2020. The May 2027 date is scheduled and has not been reached.

The labour codes

The Code on Wages, 2019 was passed without referral and received assent on 8 August 2019. The other three 2019 Bills did go to the Standing Committee on Labour, chaired by Bhartruhari Mahtab. The committee presented its Fourth Report on the Occupational Safety Bill on 11 February 2020. It submitted its Eighth Report on the Industrial Relations Bill on 23 April 2020, during the lockdown, and its Ninth Report on the Code on Social Security on 31 July 2020. I have not established the dates on which the second and third were formally laid on the Table, so those two are dates of submission.

The government then withdrew all three Bills on 19 September 2020 and introduced new 2020 Bills the same day. PRS wrote at the time that the new Bills differed significantly from the ones the committee had examined. They did not go back to the committee. PRS’s daily note for 22 September records that many Opposition members walked out and that the Lok Sabha discussed and passed the three codes in about three hours. The Rajya Sabha passed them on 23 September, and assent followed on 28 September 2020.

The committee stage therefore happened and was then set aside. The failure here came after scrutiny: the government took the committee’s time, then replaced the Bills the committee had read.

The laws then waited. The four codes were notified into force on 21 November 2025, 75 months after assent for the Code on Wages and 62 months for the other three. The central government released draft rules for consultation on 30 December 2025 and notified final rules on 8 May 2026. Law-firm alerts from KPMG and AZB list all four sets of Central Rules as notified that day, although Business Standard’s first report said only the Industrial Relations and Wages rules were out. I follow the later and more detailed accounts. Measured to the rules, the wait from assent was 81 months for the Wages Code and 67 for the other three.

Labour is on the Concurrent List, so states write their own rules as well. Karnataka published draft state rules under two of the codes in January 2026, four months before the Union Rules arrived. State rules run on their own timetable. The Labour Secretary had hoped to have all of them notified by 31 October 2026. Business Today reported on 20 November that several states had still not done so, and named seven (Andhra Pradesh, Arunachal Pradesh, Bihar, Dadra and Nagar Haveli, Gujarat, Lakshadweep and Puducherry) with final rules under all four codes.

A Bill that took six years and passed in under an hour

The Personal Data Protection Bill was introduced in December 2019. A Joint Parliamentary Committee examined it for about two years, held 78 sittings, totalling 184 hours and 20 minutes by the report’s own count, and presented its report on 16 December 2021. The government withdrew the Bill on 3 August 2022, eight months after the report.

A new Bill, the Digital Personal Data Protection Bill, 2023, was introduced on 3 August 2023. ThePrint counted a discussion of about 50 minutes with eight members taking part, and the Internet Freedom Foundation counted 52 minutes and nine members. The Lok Sabha passed it on 7 August. The Rajya Sabha passed it on 9 August and the President gave assent on 11 August 2023.

Then the Act waited for its Rules. The Digital Personal Data Protection Rules were notified on 13 November 2025, 27 months after assent and 10 months after the draft Rules appeared. Under the phased schedule that Hogan Lovells sets out, the Data Protection Board came into being at once and the core duties on notice, consent and security safeguards apply from 13 May 2027. From assent to that date is 45 months, close to four years in which no data fiduciary is bound by the main obligations. The second phase arrived on 13 November 2026, when the rule on Consent Managers took effect and MeitY opened the registration portal. The reports I found for that week do not mention any appointment of a Chairperson or members to the Data Protection Board.

The government did consult on the Rules. The Press Information Bureau says it received 6,915 inputs. So the public did get a hearing, late, on the part of the law that decides what the law means in practice. A Joint Committee had given the earlier Bill a long hearing and the government dropped that Bill. The sequence supports two readings and I do not think the evidence picks between them. One is that scrutiny at the Bill stage was skipped and the work was done later. The other is that the long committee process did not produce a law, and a quicker route did. Both are in the record.

Three minutes to repeal

The farm laws sit at the other end of the distribution. The ordinances were promulgated on 5 June 2020, the Acts received assent on 27 September 2020, and the Supreme Court stayed them on 12 January 2021. That is 221 days from the first ordinance to the stay, of which 107 were as Acts. The laws did bind people for a while, and they bound them against vigorous protest.

The repeal Bill passed on 29 November 2021, the first day of the Winter Session. Deccan Herald counted three minutes in the Lok Sabha and nine in the Rajya Sabha. Other outlets gave four minutes for the Lok Sabha, and the Tribune recorded the agriculture minister saying both sides wanted repeal and discussion was unnecessary. The Opposition said earlier repeals had been debated, and the Tribune report notes the Congress cited 17 repeal Bills that were discussed.

Scroll reported that the Lok Sabha Speaker would not allow a discussion unless the House was in order. Deccan Herald’s day-one report noted that the Bills had passed in September 2020 in much the same way. The repeal is the one case here where speed served the people the original laws had hurt. It is also a case where the House gave no time to ask why the laws had failed.

The case against my own argument

The criminal law codes are the best counter-example I have found. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita and the Bharatiya Sakshya Bill were introduced on 11 August 2023 and referred to the Standing Committee on Home Affairs a week later. The committee’s report was tabled on 4 December. The government withdrew the three Bills and reintroduced them on 12 December with some of the committee’s recommendations built in.

The Lok Sabha passed the second set on 20 December, with 97 of its Opposition members suspended, a count that reached 143 across both Houses by that date. The three Acts received assent on 25 December 2023 and came into force on 1 July 2024, 189 days later. The Centre fixed that date by three notifications of 23 February 2024 (S.O. 848(E) for the BNSS, 849(E) for the Sakshya Adhiniyam and 850(E) for the BNS), which are published by the Home Ministry. One provision, section 106(2) of the BNS on hit-and-run deaths, was left out of the commencement and has not been brought into force.

Three things follow. First, committee scrutiny happened and shaped the text, which is how the system is meant to work. Second, the passage still took place without a large part of the Opposition in the House, so referral does not secure a debate. Third, the lag from assent to effect was the shortest of the four cases, a little over six months. That is evidence that a committee stage and a short lag can go together, and it is the strongest point against the claim that scrutiny and speed trade off. I cannot say from these cases alone that scrutiny shortened the lag. The Home Ministry gave a date for commencement within two months of assent, and that choice may have been political as much as procedural.

The data protection history shows the opposite failure. A long and public committee process ended with the government withdrawing the Bill. The argument I can defend is smaller than the title suggests. Committee scrutiny does not guarantee a good law or a prompt one, and a quick passage does not by itself explain a long lag. What the record supports is that the stage where Parliament does not look, the drafting of rules and the setting of dates, is where the delay accumulates in the two cases with long lags.

The budget as a limiting case

The Union Budget shows what happens when floor time is used up before the work is done. PRS’s note on the Budget Session 2026, which ran from 28 January to 18 April, reports 31 sitting days and says 77 per cent of the budget was guillotined, meaning passed without discussion. The Lok Sabha spent about 35 hours on the Union Budget and the expenditure of two ministries, Agriculture and Railways.

A guillotined demand is voted without debate, and the spending it authorises is then governed by executive guidelines. I treat the budget as a limiting case of the same pattern. I have no lag series for expenditure to test it against, so I make no claim beyond the figures above.

Where this stands now

The current House has used committees for two Bills of the kind this essay is about. The FCRA Bill, 2026 was referred to a Joint Parliamentary Committee during the Monsoon Session. The Indian Statistical Institute Bill, 2026 was introduced on 3 August and, by the PRS brief of 30 October, referred to the Standing Committee on Finance on 1 September.

The ISI Bill is a useful test. Business Standard reported that it replaces a 33-member council with an 11-member Board of Governance and that faculty fear a loss of autonomy. PRS’s brief says the Visitor’s approval is required to appoint and remove the Director. Faculty objected within days of introduction, and the Bill went to a committee within a month. Where there is organised objection from people with standing, the committee route is still used.

As of 20 November 2026 no date for the Winter Session has been officially announced. The Hans India reported on 15 November that it was likely to begin in the first week of December, with the government also weighing whether to extend the unprorogued Monsoon Session. Any figure for the 18th Lok Sabha in this essay runs to 13 August 2026 and will move.

What I would change

I have three proposals and one reservation. They follow from the four cases, and they are mine.

The first is to publish draft rules with the Bill. The labour codes waited 62 to 75 months for commencement and 67 to 81 for rules. Data protection waited 27 months for rules. If the draft Rules had been tabled alongside each Bill, members would have been voting on how the law would work. That costs the ministry a drafting exercise it will do anyway.

The second is a statutory commencement date, or a fixed outer limit, written into each Act. The labour codes and the data protection Act left commencement to a government notification with no deadline. An outer limit, say 12 months, would make the lag a matter of accountability, and a minister who missed it would have to explain why to the House.

The third is a standing report on the lag. PRS already tracks Bills and committee referrals. A table of assent date, commencement date and rules date for every Act would let any member see which laws are waiting. I could not find a published series of this kind and built Figure 3 by hand from separate notifications.

The reservation concerns referral. I do not argue for sending every Bill to a committee. Britain’s practice, as PRS describes it, is a useful comparison and an uncertain model, because the cases above show that a committee stage can be ignored, can end in withdrawal, or can be followed by a government that replaces the text. A rule that governs the quality of the committee stage matters as much as one that fixes the share of Bills referred. I would start with the three proposals above, which can be adopted without agreeing on that.

What I could not establish

I did not find a clean measure of how much of the lag comes from drafting and how much from consultation, from inter-ministerial clearance, or from waiting on state governments. The Ministry of Labour and Employment holds those dates. A question to the ministry on the sequence of internal approvals for the labour rules would answer it.

The reports of the Standing Committee on Labour are on the 2019 Bills and not the 2020 Bills that Parliament passed. Anyone quoting the committee as having endorsed the 2020 Codes is quoting a report about a different text.

Counts of minutes of floor discussion differ between sources by a few minutes, as the data protection and farm law cases show. I report the range and name the source for each.

Further reading

How often Parliament scrutinises Bills · PRS, Functioning of the 17th Lok Sabha · PRS, 70 years of Parliament · PRS, Vital Stats Winter Session 2025 · PRS, Functioning of Parliament in the Monsoon Session 2026

The labour codes · PRS, Issues for Consideration on the 2020 Labour Codes · PRS, Code on Wages (Central) Rules, 2026 · DLA Piper India on the Central Rules · JSA Law on the Central Rules

Data protection · PRS, Joint Committee report summary · Hogan Lovells on the phased commencement · PIB note on the DPDP Rules · Internet Freedom Foundation on the Lok Sabha passage

The farm laws repeal · Scroll · Down To Earth · Tribune

The criminal law codes · MHA, Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam with commencement notification · PRS, Bharatiya Nyaya (Second) Sanhita, 2023 · PRS, Winter Session 2023 wrap · Bar and Bench on the passage

The Union Budget and current Bills · PRS, Vital Stats Budget Session 2026 · PRS, Indian Statistical Institute Bill, 2026

Varna Sri Raman is a development economist and a former Dr. Manmohan Singh Fellow with AIPC. She writes on policy design and public data at policygrounds.press.

Write a comment ...

Varna

Show your support

If you've found value in my writing, consider supporting ImpactMojo (www.impactmojo.in)—a free, open-source knowledge platform I founded to make high-quality monitoring, evaluation, and development practice resources accessible to practitioners across South Asia. Your contribution helps us keep all courses, tools, and learning materials freely available to the thousands of development professionals who can't access expensive certifications or paywalled knowledge. Every donation goes directly toward developing new content, maintaining our interactive labs, and expanding resources that bridge the gap between academic rigour and on-the-ground practice. Thank you for helping democratise development knowledge.

Recent Supporters

Write a comment ...